Showing posts with label Assignment Feedback. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Assignment Feedback. Show all posts

Saturday, 2 February 2013

Feedback from Assignment 5

Received  feedback from Assignment 5. Feedback was more detailed  in a previous assignments with specific comments on the images as well as some more general thoughts about the approach

Tutor considers the use of images produced for the business "was an interesting choice for your final piece" and added that “would like to see [me] build considerably on supporting notes from the task demonstrating considerable thought to the selection of subject matter. The images need to appear without text first with a clear indication whether you were illustrating a title section or a poem.”

This requirement is difficult for me to consider without substantial reformatting of the original blog so I've decided to rework the block within this feedback session encompassing the comments. This provides an opportunity to consider both the presentation comments as well as the general comments.

Quality

Tutor has had issues before ways quality issues. I have to say I find this a difficult one to resolve. I have been clear that I use the OCA work as being entirely blog based. I set this out early on when doing the previous course and see no reason to change my view.

Quality is clearly a subjective factor; I am using the same approach as for previous course during which the quality of images was not raised, and I scored  highly for quality of outcome. I have used my images for competitions where no judge has made any adverse comment on quality or lack of sharpness. One has to conclude that tutor is more concerned about quality than others, specifically sharpness. It is a specific example of the subjectivity involved with this course: tutor focusses on this angle, previous tutor had his particular points to focus on. Printing might improve quality, but I shall not be deflected from my stated aim when commencing OCA: everything has to be digital. I adapt most of what I do to tutor's comments, else there is little point in doing the course, but online is a holy grail.

Tutor also considers  “navigation of your site particularly frustrating on this occasion”. One has to query as to why this comment emerges during the feedback for assignment five when the blog and layouts have been in existence and viewed by tutor for several months. The idea she mentions of using a hyperlink to each of the Assignments is a good one and has been adopted.

I now set out the blog with revisions as suggested by tutor, These are threefold:

1. Adding some commentary after reviewing work by other photographers who have used text in their images;
2. Ordering images so the original and the image as it appears  on the website are together;
3. Building on notes.

I have also amended my comment concerning the link to Poetry Space following the navigational difficultirs tutor experienced. Feedback on tutor's comments on specific images is included with the relevant image in the revised blog. Whilst there are specific comments from tutor that I do not agree with or do not understand (that is inevitably the case), I have taken on board most of the comments, and made appropriate amendments. I consider that the end result is better than the original. The original Assignment was rushed slightly so as to get feedback in time for assessment, and perhaps that showed.

The revised text is in blue.

People and place on assignment

The aim of this assignment is to set out a basic brief for a commission. The notes are clear that professional photography differs from amateur photography in that it is "performed to order" rather than requiring any greater degree of "competence or special skill or technical quality". What we seek are images that fulfil a brief. We have looked at the notion of narrative during this course, and the consequent relationship of images and words, and this assignment is an extension of the key concept of narrative: images that illustrate a message, only this time it is prescribed to a professional brief.

The choice of subject is personal, so I have selected a real example of how my images are being used in a professional way: for use in Poetry Space, an online poetry publishing business owned and run by my wife. I am grateful to her, the company and the authors mentioned for their assistance and permission to publish the extracts, poems and covers. This Assignment has been a long term project; I have steadily worked on material for inclusion for several months, adapting and including material as my learning has developed. I have used examples that demonstrate particular emphasis on people and/or place.

Images are used in the business in three main ways:
  • to provide a dynamic gallery on the website; 
  • to illustrate particular poems; and
  • to provide book covers
The brief therefore is to take images that are appropriate for the particular use: this is to a degree an artistic choice so we discuss what sort of image will work in each case. It is important to recognise that this is a two way process; sometimes an image will complement a poem or an extract, on occasion there is the opportunity to provide an image for a given poem or book title. This is demonstrated by the following examples.

To see the images in a live environment, visit Poetry Space website where there is a showcase of poems including these images (Poetry Showcase) and a shop (Poetry Space Shop) with the illustrated titles. The moving banner images are on the front page.


Background

One photographer who uses text as an integral part of his imagery is Duane Michals. An example is below. Michals provides an interesting insight into what the man might be thinking as he picks up the image at some time in the future. His words add a distinct dimension as well as some emotion.



http://www.shanelavalette.com/images/journal/duanemichals01.jpg
Michals D (unknown) This Photograph is my Proof [online image]. Private collection. Available from www.shanelavalette.com/images/journal/ [Accessed 2 February 2013]


The image below is in a similar vein, this time the words are added as a third person commenting on the relationship between the subjects. Again, I think this is effective; slightly moot point whether it is necessary to incorporate as part of the image but it provides a sort of postcard effect that is unusual and effective. Few people seem to have worked on this idea in more recent years.


https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgK-R0-zoAuVA437Co2ZEBSIVEvLcx2lsE4Ntj_GETDVGcgwVvhSgO9_7dhPwmLVqeUg11WTaz599-3GsPdkGBu7t0hop8j1J4-m15NvSbbLLDwRzBQCPl7sMlokWHcV4Ti0BTeScV5-N80/s1600/4S04763.jpg
Michals D (unknown) Certain Words Must be Said [online image]. Private collection. Available from www.shanelavalette.com/images/journal/ [Accessed 2 February 2013]
Jim Goldberg includes text more directly on images as below; the outcome is similar in that Goldberg imputes thoughts to the subject.


http://www.culturecritic.co.uk/_furniture/exhibitions/goldberg176x176.jpg
Goldberg J (unknown) Untitled [online image]. Private collection. Available from /www.culturecritic.co.uk/_furniture/exhibitions/goldberg [Accessed 2 February 2013]
Looking at covers,  The Economist has always provided inspiring digital images, often combining graphic art with photography as in this example:



The use of a simple image provides opportunity to add text on the image without losing the message. 

Book covers frequently also use a combination of photographs with manipulation. An example is Stephen King's book Under the Dome where the cover designer has added a subtle reference to the title using a photogrpah with manipulation. The result is an interesting vibrant and captivating cover.


Under the Dome by Stephen King
Art Director: Rex Bonomelli

A simpler effect is this cover designed by John Fulbrook III. The image is directly relevant to the title, but evoking a sense of past as well.

At Swim Two Boys by Jamie O’Neill
Designed by John Fulbrook III
I was interested to find a cover of a poetry collection; the cover of Richard Hugo's Making it Certain It Goes On caught my eye. I like the subtlety of the wheatfield panning out into the distance; there is a feeling of certainty about the image as well as the sense of "going on". The cover of As It Is below is in a similar vein.

Making Certain It Goes On by Richard Hugo
Designed by Darren Haggar


Dynamic gallery

The website has a series of images with quotes from contributing poets as a moving banner. These are three examples, with the original image first:

 
Canon EOS 450D with EF24-105mm f/4L IS USM. f4; 1/60; ISO 200 focal length 105mm

© Philip Lyons

The first image was taken during a downpour in Kiev - the chair was actually used by a self appointed taxi organiser who abandoned his post once the rain came. The image was taken because the scene evokes a sense of abandonment. The words fit beautifully: the hope of the occupier of the chair has indeed been washed away.

Canon EOS 450D with 10-22mm f/4L IS USM. f4; 1/15; ISO 1600 focal length 22mm

© Azadeh Kallili

The positioning of the figure in the second image (taken in the tunnel on Bristol-Bath cycle track) is key to matching the words in the extract from Azadeh Kallili's poem. She is actually walking towards the photographer, but this is indistinct - she could be walking away or stationary. But the beauty of this conjunction is the ambiguity in the quote. Does the the word "face" mean literally look towards the sun or is it used colloquially in the sense that "I do not want to go out in the sun today". There is ambiguity in the words and in the image.

This image also demonstrates a technical point: that the positioning of images on the website requires images in 2:1 dimensions  rather than the typical 3:2 or 4:3 from a SLR. Consequently the image has had to be cropped at the bottom so the words can be placed on a clearly visible part. In isolation the image would look wrong but in context it seems not to matter simply because the addition of the words has effectively created a new image.

(Tutor thinks that it is a shame to have cropped the image. I did made clear in the original blog that the cropping was a function of the need to fit in a particular space within poetry space website.)

Canon EOS 450D with EF24-105mm f/4L IS USM. f4.5; 1/60; ISO 400 focal length 24mm



© Philip Lyons


The third example is less ambiguous but the words and the image of Westonbirt Arboretum fit perfectly - the sunlight through the trees with the autumn colours adding vibrance and interest and an inviting space in the middle foreground for the meeting suggested by the extract from Philip Lyons' poem. I took the image because of the light and colour; there is a sense of depth in the image. I di dno think of the foreground space being a meeting place, but this is a good example of where the combination of words and text add a dimension that the photogrpah alone does not necessarily evoke, in the mould of Dulas' work above.

Tutor feels this picture is too literal and lacking in hidden depth, and implies that this might not want this image on a final stage of the course. I disagree and see no reason to extract the image.


This selection provides examples of how words and images can enrich one another, a concept explored further with images and complete poems.

Illustration of poems

Canon EOS 450D with EF24-105mm f/4L IS USM. f6.7; 1/350; ISO 200 focal length 32mm

This image of the sled beneath an oak tree on Cock Road Ridge in Kingswood is used to complement Moira Andrew's poem:

First Snow of Winter

We wake to a world bewitched,
a black and white negative
of itself. Hunchback gardens
crouch beneath a gun-grey sky
like a flock of gulls
huddled shoulder to shoulder

on some salty shoreline.
Feathered trees thrust out bare branches, 
wide as wings,
across the bleak horizon.
Blackbirds balance on the
snow-sheathed fence, their
beaks ripping bright holes

in the colourless morning.
© Moira Andrew

The poem evokes mental images of the scenes described, and an image of snow landscape - in particular the "thrust out bare branches" of the poem - hopefully adds to that. The oak tree standing almost defiantly captivated me, as well as the gradation of colour and texture as the snow works round the trunk. The sled adds colour and human interest.

Tutor would like to see some emotional response which I've added.


Canon EOS 450D with EF24-105mm f/4L IS USM. f4; 1/4; ISO 1600 focal length 105mm


Cardboard City

Come visit my castle the next time you’re in the city?
Look, see. It’s not like the others, filth and mess.
They don’t fold up papers, conserve for other days
Living for the moment, whereas I think ahead
I’ve even made a window; it opens inwards and out
With that homely touch, I put a frill up.
I’ve got thick mattresses in all the bedrooms,
Lined with today’s newspapers, if you open up the window
With the light of the moon, you can read in bed.
A kitchen, with a basin for the sink
Of course I only use royal china, milk just two days out of date!
When the hard long day is over, of kerbs, park benches
Searching through bins, I get caught up in that evening rush.
I imagine the walls made out of granite, the roof slate
With chimneys keeping each room away from the damp
Gatehouse with its keeper, looking after my estate
So don’t forget, come to the city within a city,
Everything is manmade; you’ll see some amazing sites
You see I use to be an engineer.

© Johanna Boal

The link between image and words is subtle here, the crushed can symbolizes a life that has been changed beyond recognition, as well as being a tangible sign of life on the streets.

Tutor wonders why there is a strong colour cast on the crushed can image. It is not deliberate and is not designed to add to the meaning. The fact that the image was taken in tungsten lives is irrelevant to its use as an illustration of the poem.



Canon EOS 450D with EF24-105mm f/4L IS USM. f22; 1/125; ISO 200 focal length 55mm

Susan Jane Sims was so inspired by the image of a solitary balloon stuck below the roof of Cabot Circus shopping centre that she wrote the following poem:



Windows Of My Mind



When you died

I thought you'd float

beyond the blue



and though the pull
is strong

you never quite
slip from view.


You're there,

pressed against

the windows of my mind
© Susan Jane Sims


Here the poet has added personalized feeling to what is almost an abstract image. I took the image because of contrasts: between the deep blue of the background and the pink of the ballon; between the quasi rectangular roof and the round balloon. But that is me as a photographer. I am intrigued by  the poets's focus on the balloon only, she makes no observation of the geometry of the roof, yet photographically this is as important as the balloon. In image terms, the solitary point of the balloon contrasts with the geometrical pattern; they balance each other. The poet has focussed on the balloon only, thereby adding a different dimension for the reader.

Tutor says I have told us nothing about the taking of the image. I think there is a misunderstanding here: the whole point is that there is a two way dynamic between the imagery and the commentary on it by the poem. I have however added some notes as to what struck me originally.

Book covers

A few images of mine have been used for books of poems published by Poetry Space.

Canon EOS 450D with EF24-105mm f/4L IS USM. f4; 1/90; ISO 200 focal length 98mm
© Poetry Space Ltd
(The image has had a black border applied for appearance on Amazon bookstore)

Philip Lyons' book is a collection of poetry written over several years; the title was the author's own - the publisher and I sought to illustrate with a simple image. This image (taken in Hyde Park) of a person engrossed in an activity that we can only conjecture at seemed to work well.

Tutor can see the image works well with the title of the book - the rough edges to the jeans and hat adding to a "sense of reality."

Canon EOS 450D with EF24-105mm f/4L IS USM. f8; 1/45; ISO 400 focal length 50mm
© Poetry Space Ltd
(The image has had a black border applied for appearance on Amazon bookstore)

The concept for the cover of Words that Signify, an anthology of poems entered for a competition run by Poetry Space, arose from a street theatre experience that I saw, where the artist was drawing blind:


My view was that the image of the artist writing or drawing blind was not quite right for a book of poetry but the concept could be adapted to work better with the book title, consequently we have a thoughtful and intense expression from the chalk author, who has written two words on a brick wall. Are they random? What do they signify? These are the sorts of questions the image is trying to evoke as part of the cover.

Tutor asks "why these words?" A slight misconception here: the chalk author was not given a brief as to what to write and was never asked what "feather" and "hid" meant to him - that was the point of the title.


Canon EOS 450D with EF24-105mm f/4L IS USM. f13; 1/60; ISO 200 focal length 91mm
© Poetry Space Ltd 
(The image has had a black border applied for appearance on Amazon bookstore)

When asked to illustrate Through a Child's Eyes I suggested that we avoid a stereotypical WW2 type image - the 1940 sepia image of a boy and girl disembarking from a train in the middle of the English countryside, for example. It seemed appropriate to use a modern image and this image of a boy looking down from the John Hancock Center in Chicago works well.



The image as taken (above) was not suitable for a book cover - the title would be too easily lost in the background and the focus needed to be on the boy only, not on the object of his scrutiny. Consequently I used a high key black and white conversion in Silver Efex Pro2, thus almost eliminating the background, leaving just sufficient that we can see the boy is not a carefully selected and cut profile from another image. On a practical point, the conversion left sufficient white space for the title and author. The author herself was delighted by the image, immediately seeing the significance of it clearly being contemporary and multi cultural. It is important that our reflections of history acknowledge the view of today's audience and how it looks at the words of the past.

The question the tutor has asked is how I get from first image to second. Not quite sure what she means here - I have set out the photogpraphic process.

Conclusion

I have presented nine (the brief is between eight and twelve) of my images as used by Poetry Space. It is not only gratifying to see one's work being used in this way, but also it has challenged me to think about what works artistically for the audience and the client. It is photography in context - images being used to illustrate, and hopefully enhance, other people's work. Furthermore, we can see how the words enhance some of the images; the phrase on the tunnel image is a personal favourite, and I also particularly like the symbiosis of Words Of My Mind and the image of the balloon.

The Assignment has been a pleasure to do; the culmination of the course and a personal collection of images in practice. I have gained most from the People and Place module in my understanding of context and narrative. TAOP is concerned mainly about the technical aspects of single image photography; in this module we have begun to move towards photography serving a purpose, whether that be an artistic narrative or, as in this Assignment, a more commercial emphasis.





Saturday, 19 January 2013

Feedback from Assignment 4

Tutor's feedback from Assignment 4 Sense of Place was positive. Tutor notes that I have maintained a good pace and nearly finished now. Tutor understands my aim is to go for the Photography degree; this is not necessarily true. I am taking each stage at a time and will see how far I wish to go, which may or may not be the complete degree. I am aiming for assessment for this course.

Tutor likes first image of shoe shining parlour - "a very powerful image". Pleased with this as I thought this was the best image and one that I am considering submitting for competitions. Tutor notes the Abuse of Power headline on the newspaper, something that I had not noticed.

Favourable comments on the election win ("works very well") and the subway, washing line and High Line images are also well received as providing "a more challenging and considered view of New York."

Tutor is less convinced about the diner image - "the message [from the pamphlet] doesn't fit seamlessly with the almost empty diner." The conclusion is perhaps the image is trying too much and therefore "lacks a strong message."

On reflection, I can understand the comment; the image was actually the sixth of 6 to be chosen for the in-depth treatment for the travel publication so was marginal.

I have more difficulty with the comments on the white image ("lacks a strong message"); yellow cab and Flat Iron image ("''gives viewer little in terms of new information") and Chinatown image.I think the Assignment commentary on these images was clear: these are specifically images that were considered and rejected for exactly the reasons set out by Tutor. I thought I had made clear that these were six images that were considered but would not be in my final selection of six. I followed the brief of reviewing twelve, and selecting six.

On a technical point, tutor says some images appear grainy or have noise issues. Reviewing images online again, I agree that three show distinct noise and have applied Topaz DeNoise3 to these as follows (in each case the original image is followed by the noise reduced image). I overdid the sharpening and dynamic range during post processing. Topaz DeNoise mitigates the negative effects of these..








Tutor suggests good quality prints "will give the work a lift for assessment purposes." This is possibly true but I have set out on this course with the express aim of being paperless. We live in a digital age (even BJP gets more digital subscribers than printed copy) and I like to reflect that in my submissions and assessments. I am green in the sense of not printing items unless necessary (this is a mantra that I impress on my team at work and have changed processes to eliminate unnecessary paper). There are those who say digital images are not the same quality as printed images but in my experience this is not true.

In the summary, tutor says this is "an interesting mix...giving a good indication of where your heart lies when it comes to taking images." I appreciate this comment and that throughout the feedbacks tutor has noticed my enthusiasm and determination to present good work that fulfils the brief.


Sunday, 18 November 2012

Feedback from Assignment 3

Received feedback on day returned from New York.

Plaesed that turot notes "commitment to the course" - it has been less easy now working four days per week and with marathon training (very disappointing that New York marathon was cancelled after all the preparation) but determined to maintain some momentum on the course.

Subject wise, tutor has noted the variety induced by choosing public places and places of work.

Kiev metro

Tutor likes the grainy black and white as emphasising the lack of modernization.

M Shed Bristol

More bright and cheerful, befitting a leisure attraction. Tutor comments that bus picture is very bright, noting that may be caused by composite image. This is true to a degree, as I selected the image from Photomatix that provided the richest colours, but alternatives were available. I take the point that perhaps the brightness of the green and red take the eye left and right. Here is the image less saturated compared to the original below:





Perhaps works better less saturated - not sure myself, rather prefer the richness of the original.

Silhouetted picture "works very well"; I thought this was the best shot of the portfolio, and actually one of the best I have taken for OCA work. I shall enter this in competitions. The composition is perfect with the people on the left, and the Matthew on the right.

Balloon is "very bright and busy"; the annual balloon festival in Bristol is indeed a bright and busy occasion, and tried to reflect that in the image.

Edge Equipment Hire, Runcorn

Images "work really well to demonstrate a functional place set out for purpose".  Again, pleased that the message trying to convey is being understood. Tutor looking for more clarity on the shot. Am I working with cable release or remote? No, not on these although do use remote sometimes.

The City Academy, Bristol

 Tutor queries sharpness of first shot and whether file size is issue. Answer, no, always shoot in RAW and convert to medium size jpeg for web. It may be a function of web.

Tutor likes library image but is "less keen on the the third image with students partially hidden behind over-hanign lights". Agree with that; I am usually meticulous with taking and choosing images with sound composition but actually did not take heed of the blocking nature of the lights in this case. It was a mistake.

Bonawe Iron Furnace

 Tutor prefers the second, non compositional, shot as "clearer, sharper detailon the itmes on display." Wonders whether images could "be a fraction lower". Let's see with second image:





The second image is as presented, the first has been adjusted to reduce white balance, brightness and vibrance. The first probably does look "truer" but perhaps less eye catching - to be frank, the scene was not particularly photogenic so I worked to make it so.

As a general point, demonstrated with this and the bus image, I like to be bold, to stretch the viewer's perception as to what is genuine and what is constructed. Freeman himself makes the point in The Photographer's Mind that people on the whole prefer vibrant colours. This may not be to everyone's taste, and certainly does not work in some images, but is my style.

One other point I note from tutor's point concerns sharpness of images, this was mentioned last time so is evidently a concern on some images. Two comments:
  1.  I do not have very steady hands and consequently sometimes snatch the shutter button. One tries to mitigate but does not always work;
  2. Despite this, it is not something that is frequently raised with my work - not at all in TAOP and not in feedback from competition images. I weed out images that are clearly not sharp enough to use and post process nearly all images for sharpness.



Sunday, 9 September 2012

Feedback from Assignment 2



Received feedback from Assignment 2.

Sometimes, you do something and you have a feel as to whether a piece of work is good or not. It is often a function of how easy it was to do; how well it flows. I had an instinct that my Assignment would be well received; I thought it was a good idea; I enjoyed doing it; and the narrative flowed. My best work has tended to be when I work my day to day photography with the OCA course. This  Assignment was done while on holiday in Scotland; as said in the Assignment itself, the structure required of the Assignment, and the need to do some background research, fulfilled me as a photographer much more than taking random shots on the day.

Tutor agrees with subject matter: "You made a really great choice of subject...". Further, "The images that you have produced for this assignment are strong."

Pleased to see that tutor agrees that the narrative is strong and notes the flow. This was a result of having the idea in my head of how the story should be told, and using the images to demonstrate this, rather than fitting narrative around the images.

Tutor comments that the images of the girl and the woman eating are not so necessary, albeit acknowledging my justification. I understand the comment, and, to be honest, maybe was sufficiently taken with these images to work the narrative round them, an indication of the interaction between the narrative and the photography.

On technical point, tutor says she would like to see the information on camera settings used. I had asked previously whether settings information should be included in captions and received following response:



"To give you feedback on the technical aspects of your work, it useful to have settings to refer to. I don't see a need to necessarily put these in the blog though and not for the exercises. Now in this respect the AOP is more heavily centred around camera techniques and therefore these perhaps have more relevance than they will as you progress upwards."
I originally took this to mean that settings information is not required, but what is actually being said is that settings information does not need to be on captions. Will include as appended information in future.


Tutor says "On occasion the images on screen could be a tad sharper", adding whether a faster shutter speed and/or a monopod would have helped. Short answer is yes for both, although monopod would not have been usable for some of the shots. A better solution might have been to do have some further post processing. Having spent time on other Scotland images, I have refreshed my knowledge of Topaz products. Topaz Adjust and Topaz Detail both have excellent sharpening possibilities, boosting structure or adding sharpening. These work far better than the unsharp mask tool in Photoshop, and would have overcome the slight problem noted. Compare the before and after on the following two images:

per the blog

sharpened using Topaz Detail

per the blog

sharpened using Topaz Detail 2

The sharpened images are better, bringing out detail in the mountains as well as the subjects. TD2 does not work for all images but will use for most assignment images in future.

Overall conclusion is "well done..interesting collection of images...your analysis and supporting notes are very strong".  Pleased with this feedback.

Also good progress noted with learning log. Need of do some more work on this  over next few weeks.

Overall, have enjoyed this Chapter very much. I thought it would be interesting, as have taken a lot of people unaware shots in the past; I am not fazed by the prospect of photographing people when they do not know. The main learning outcome has been to understand the concept of narrative better (along with the reading that have noted elsewhere in the learning log)  but also some technical points about using wide angle and zoom lenses. I understand better the concept of having something to say via the medium of photography.